Weekly News Recap (29 April - 5 May 2024)
© Photo by World Bank Photo Collection via Flickr
- Bosnia and Herzegovina: Bosnian Serb Nationalist Charged with Genocide Denial
-
ICJ: Ecuador Sues Mexico Over Asylum to Convicted Vice President
-
USA: Former US President Donald Trump Fined Over Gag Order Violation
-
ICJ: Nicaragua’s Request for Measures Against Germany in Israel Arms Dispute Denied
-
USA: Congressman Indicted on Charges of Bribery, Unlawful Foreign Influence, and Money Laundering
-
UK: High Court Rules Government Climate Strategy Inadequate and Violates Climate Legislation
International Justice Section
Bosnia and Herzegovina: Bosnian Serb Nationalist Charged with Genocide Denial
On 29 April 2024, the Bosnian state prosecution reported that Vojin Pavlovic, leader of the Eastern Alternative NGO, was charged with inciting ethnic, racial, and religious hatred by denying and attempting to justify the Srebrenica genocide perpetrated by Bosnian Serb forces in 1995. Pavlovic reportedly placed posters in Srebrenica and Bratunac that denied the genocide during the period leading up to the annual commemoration of the Srebrenica massacres. Additionally, he organised and spoke at a public meeting where he tried to justify the genocide. This act follows recent legal amendments in Bosnia and Herzegovina that prohibit the glorification of war criminals and genocide denial. Pavlovic is also on trial for another charge related to his public celebration of Ratko Mladic, a convicted genocide perpetrator, exacerbating tensions with the local Bosniak community. His actions have reignited fears among Bosniaks in Bratunac, a region deeply affected by the atrocities of the 1992-95 Bosnian war.
https://balkaninsight.com/2024/04/29/bosnian-serb-nationalist-indicted-for-genocide-denial/
ICJ: Ecuador Sues Mexico Over Asylum to Convicted Vice President
On 30 April 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) commenced the two-day hearing of the case brought by Ecuador against Mexico, accusing it of violating international laws by granting political asylum to Jorge Glas, Ecuador’s former vice president who was convicted of corruption. Glas, involved in the Odebrecht bribery case and under investigation for misusing earthquake relief funds, received asylum despite ongoing legal proceedings against him. This incident led to further tensions as Ecuador’s President Daniel Noboa ordered the arrest of Glas from the Mexican Embassy, breaching the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations which protects embassy inviolability. This move was condemned internationally, prompting Mexico to also file a case against Ecuador at the ICJ. Ecuador’s lawsuit claims Mexico interfered in its internal affairs and violated diplomatic asylum conventions by offering refuge to a convicted individual actively facing legal charges, challenging both legal precedents and international diplomatic norms. The ICJ finished hearing the case on 1 May and will now deliberate on the matter.
https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/194/194-20240501-pre-01-00-en.pdf
USA: Former US President Donald Trump Fined Over Gag Order Violation
On 30 April 2024, former US President Donald Trump was held in contempt and fined $9,000 for breaching a gag order in his New York trial over alleged hush money payments to adult film star Stormy Daniels. Trump, who frequently engages on social media, was restricted by the court from making public comments that might influence jurors or witnesses. Despite this, prosecutors documented that Trump posted and shared content related to the case on his social media platform and campaign site at least ten times. Trump argued these were instances of “protected political speech” and challenged the equivalence of reposts to original posts. However, Judge Juan Merchan, dismissing these arguments, treated reposts with the same seriousness as original posts, emphasising that Trump’s actions were intentional to boost visibility and imply endorsement. The court rejected all but one of Trump’s free speech defence claims and ordered the removal of the posts, cautioning that future violations could lead to jail time. In response, Trump vocally criticised the judge and the trial on his social media, claiming his free speech rights were being violated and labelling the trial as rigged.
ICJ: Nicaragua’s Request for Measures Against Germany in Israel Arms Dispute Denied
On 30 April 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) declined Nicaragua’s request for preliminary measures against Germany in a legal dispute concerning Germany’s support for Israel. Nicaragua accused Germany of violating the Genocide Convention and other international laws by supplying arms to Israel amidst ongoing hostilities in Gaza, which escalated following a Hamas attack on 7 October 2024. Nicaragua’s claims included that Germany had authorised over €326 million in military exports to Israel in 2023, with the majority of these authorisations occurring after the start of the Gaza conflict. Additionally, Nicaragua criticised Germany for discontinuing financial support to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), affecting humanitarian assistance to Gaza. However, the ICJ, ruling 15 to 1, found that Germany had sufficiently reviewed its military export licences to ensure compliance with international humanitarian laws and had continued to support humanitarian efforts in Gaza indirectly through EU contributions, leading to the rejection of the provisional measures requested by Nicaragua.
https://www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/193/193-20240430-pre-01-00-en.pdf
CAR: Former President Charged for Crimes Against Humanity
On 1 May 2024, the Special Criminal Court (SCC) of the Central African Republic (CAR) issued an arrest warrant for former Central African Republic President François Bozizé, citing allegations of crimes against humanity, including murder, enforced disappearances, torture, and rape, committed during his tenure as a hierarchical superior and military leader. Amnesty International has urged for Bozizé, who currently resides in Guinea Bissau, to be arrested and extradited by local authorities to face these charges. The SCC, established in 2015 in partnership with the UN, aims to address the persistent impunity in CAR, which has been plagued by violent conflicts and human rights violations since 2002. Despite efforts, the court struggles with enforcement as many war crime suspects remain at large, and previous attempts to prosecute Bozizé, including a 2014 international warrant for various severe crimes, have been unsuccessful.
USA: Congressman Indicted on Charges of Bribery, Unlawful Foreign Influence, and Money Laundering
On 3 May 2024, US Congressman Henry Cuellar and his wife, Imelda, were indicted on charges including bribery, unlawful foreign influence, and money laundering. The US Department of Justice alleges that the couple accepted approximately $600,000 in bribes from an oil company owned by the government of Azerbaijan and a Mexico City bank. In return, Cuellar is accused of using his congressional position to lobby for favourable US foreign policy outcomes for Azerbaijan and to endorse policies beneficial to the Mexican bank. The funds were allegedly routed through various intermediaries and companies owned by Imelda, who purportedly did little to no legitimate work under the contracts. The Cuellars appeared in court to face multiple charges, including bribery and wire fraud, with potential lengthy prison sentences if convicted.
UK: High Court Rules Government Climate Strategy Inadequate and Violates Climate Legislation
On 3 May 2024, the UK High Court ruled that the UK Government’s climate strategy is insufficient and breaches the UK Climate Change Act 2008. This decision, coming nearly two years after a previous ruling, criticises the UK Government’s failure to align its policies with legally-binding carbon budgets. The legal action was initiated in 2022 by environmental groups, arguing that the UK Government’s measures were inadequate in reducing emissions. Despite a revised strategy, called the “Carbon Budget Delivery Plan,” the UK High Court found it lacking, citing uncertainties, vague proposals, and reliance on future technologies. Justice Sheldon upheld four out of five grounds of complaint, highlighting the UK Government’s mistaken assumptions about policy effectiveness. As a result, the UK Government must revise its plan within 12 months to meet legal obligations for carbon budgets and emission reductions. ClientEarth, one of the plaintiffs, expressed satisfaction with the ruling, emphasising the importance of implementing climate legislation effectively.
Saudi Arabia: Human Rights Organisations Allege Conviction of Women Rights Activist For Terrorism Offences
On 3 May 2024, Amnesty International and ALQST, a London-based Saudi rights organisation, in a statement called for the immediate and unconditional release of Manahel al-Otaibi, a 29-year-old fitness instructor and women’s rights activist who was sentenced to 11 years in prison by a Saudi court on 9 January 2024. According to Amnesty in the statement, the Saudi court’s decision only became public by virtue of Saudi Arabia’s formal reply to a request from the United Nations human rights office about Otaibi’s case which stated that Otaibi “was convicted of terrorist offences that have no bearing on her exercise of freedom of opinion and expression or her social media posts”. This case highlights the government’s intolerance for criticism. Despite claims of reform, Saudi Arabia continues to enforce discriminatory laws, including the male guardianship system. Otaibi’s sentencing is part of a broader crackdown on free speech, with several other individuals facing lengthy prison terms for similar offences. This repression of dissent underscores the government’s authoritarian stance and contradicts its narrative of progress and women’s empowerment.
International Peace & Security Section
Kenya: Bomb Attack on Border With Somalia Kills 5
On 29 April 2024, a bomb attack in El Wak town in northern Kenya’s Mandera County, resulted in five fatalities, with five others injured. The bomb, concealed on a donkey cart to evade detection, exploded near the Somalia border. Although no group claimed responsibility, al-Shabab militants, linked to al-Qaida and operating from Somalia, are known for similar attacks in the region. Earlier this month, suspected al-Shabab gunmen targeted El Wak hospital, injuring guards while inquiring about doctors. The group frequently conducts cross-border assaults, particularly in remote Kenyan areas like Mandera and Garissa. Al-Shabab opposes Kenya’s military presence in Somalia, part of international efforts to stabilise the nation. As the African Union Transition Mission in Somalia concludes in December 2024, Somali forces will assume greater security responsibilities, amid ongoing threats posed by extremist groups.
https://apnews.com/article/kenya-bomb-attack-border-f8cb4b2642a98ffb6ee7ff0fff6c4a04
UN: Increasing Attacks on Ukraine’s Power System Concerning
On 29 April 2024, the United Nations Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) voiced concern over the escalating civilian casualties resulting from intensified attacks by the Russian Federation armed forces on Ukraine’s electric power infrastructure and railway system. Since 22 March 2024, there have been four waves of attacks on energy facilities, resulting in six civilian deaths and at least 45 injuries. Missile strikes on 27 April 2024, damaged critical thermal power plants, affecting electricity generation even in western Ukraine, far from the frontline. Attacks on railway facilities have also claimed civilian lives, with at least 11 deaths and numerous injuries across several regions. HRMMU emphasised the significant impact of these attacks, not only causing civilian casualties but also jeopardising essential services and transportation networks relied upon by the Ukrainian population. Railway workers and power station employees have been among the casualties, with attacks disrupting power supply and leading to water supply interruptions. The resulting power outages have affected millions of households, while rolling power cuts have disrupted education schedules, especially for students reliant on online learning. HRMMU called for an end to these attacks, highlighting their devastating consequences for civilians and essential services in Ukraine.
Kenya: Burst Dam Increases Death Toll From Flooding to Over 120
On 29 April 2024, a dam in Kenya burst and killed over 40 people, escalating the death toll from ongoing floods to over 120. The incident unfolded in the Mai Mahiu area, compounding casualties from flash floods. Rescue efforts are underway, with 17 minors among the recovered bodies. The situation is exacerbated by full hydroelectric dams, posing a risk of extensive downstream flooding. East Africa is currently grappling with heavy rains, which are amplified by the El Nino weather pattern. The government postponed the new school term by a week due to safety concerns in flood-affected areas. Kenya’s infrastructure is also suffering significant damage, with roads and bridges destroyed nationwide. The Kenya Meteorological Department forecasts continued heavy rainfall until May 2024, heightening the risk of further flooding. Beyond Kenya, neighbouring countries like Burundi and Tanzania are also enduring displacement and casualties, underscoring the regional impact of climate change-driven extreme weather phenomena.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/4/29/dozens-of-people-dead-in-kenya-floods
United States: Student Protests Against Israel Continue as Riot Police Enter Universities Nationwide
On 30 April 2024, Columbia University sent the New York Police Department into Columbia University to disperse students protesting against Israel’s war in Gaza and demanding the university divest from Israel. The head of Columbia University stated that the university will not divest from Israel and during the police raid hundreds of students were arrested. Protests have erupted across the US, driven by student demands to divest from Israel amidst its aggression on Gaza and the rising death toll. The protests have led to nearly 1,000 arrests nationwide, prompting colleges to confront their financial links to Israel and issues surrounding free speech. Demonstrations have spread to Europe and Canada, with French police removing protesters from the Sorbonne. Northwestern University reached an agreement allowing peaceful protests, while the University of Southern California engaged in discussions with protesters. The protests have prompted legal action, with a lawsuit alleging Columbia failed to maintain a safe environment and calls for investigations into civil rights compliance. Despite attempts by universities to salvage commencement events, confrontations persist at high-profile institutions like Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania. Protests have sparked debate over free speech, safety, and international relations, reflecting deep divisions on campuses across the country. The situation is ongoing at the time of writing.
UN: Spillover from Gaza War Causing Deepening Humanitarian Situation in Lebanon
On 30 April 2024, the UN stated that the situation in Lebanon has reached a critical juncture, marked by a convergence of factors including escalating hostilities, a collapse in humanitarian funding, and the resultant humanitarian crisis. Amid these challenges, children as young as four are being compelled into labour, indicative of the desperation gripping communities. The conflict in Gaza has led to further displacement, leaving many Lebanese and Syrian refugee families destitute and without access to basic necessities such as clean water and healthcare. The destruction of key infrastructure, including water stations and health facilities, exacerbates the suffering of vulnerable populations. The recent intensification of hostilities, particularly along the southern border with Israel, underscores the urgency of the situation. Moreover, tensions between Lebanese and Syrian refugee communities have escalated, further straining already limited resources and exacerbating social cohesion challenges. Compounding these issues is the significant reduction in humanitarian funding, which has forced aid organisations to scale back essential services. This funding shortfall has had far-reaching consequences, affecting everything from access to safe drinking water to sewage disposal in already overburdened communities. Beyond Lebanon’s borders, the conflict’s impact extends to Palestinian refugees, who face not only dire living conditions but also the trauma of witnessing the violence in Gaza. Urgent and concerted humanitarian action is imperative to address the immediate needs of vulnerable populations, prevent further escalation of the crisis, and foster stability and resilience in the region.
EU: European Commission Investigates Meta for Potential Breaches of Digital Services Act
On 30 April 2024, the European Commission initiated an investigation into Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, to determine if it breached the Digital Services Act (DSA) in the lead-up to the June European elections. This inquiry aims to safeguard the electoral process by examining Meta’s adherence to DSA regulations, focusing on four main areas: the spread of deceptive ads and disinformation, transparency of political content, the effectiveness of its election monitoring system, and the user-friendliness of its illegal content reporting mechanisms. The investigation, which addresses consumer protection defects and potential electoral interference, could lead to the enforcement of corrective measures against Meta. This is part of broader efforts under the DSA, which mandates stringent compliance from Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs) like Facebook and Instagram to ensure a safe and transparent online environment.
United States: US Accuses Russia of Chemical Weapons Use in Ukraine War
On 2 May 2024, the United States (US) accused Russia of violating the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) by employing chloropicrin and riot control agents against Ukrainian forces, suggesting a strategic move to dislodge Ukrainian soldiers from fortified positions for tactical battlefield advantages. The US Department of State, highlighting the misuse of chemicals which are conventionally restricted to agricultural use, announced sanctions against several Russian entities linked to the country’s chemical and biological weapons programs. Despite denials from Russia and its insistence on adherence to international law, the US continues to sanction various Russian companies and state entities involved in these allegations.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/5/2/us-accuses-russia-of-using-chemical-weapons-in-ukraine-war
Türkiye: Türkiye Supports South Africa’s Genocide Case Against Israel at International Court of Justice
On 2 May 2024, Türkiye has declared its support for South Africa’s legal action against Israel in the International Court of Justice (ICJ), focusing on allegations of genocide in Gaza. This announcement, made alongside Indonesian officials, underscores Türkiye’s commitment to Palestinian support and its intention to hold Israel accountable for recent actions in Gaza. This move follows recent tensions between Türkiye and Israel, sparked by comments from Israel’s Foreign Minister Israel Katz critiquing President Recep Erdoğan’s meeting with Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh. In response, Türkiye condemned Katz’s remarks and criticised the United States for its unconditional support of Israel, which Erdoğan argues exacerbates the Palestinian issue. South Africa initiated the case against Israel, accusing it of committing genocide, and has been joined by other nations like Colombia and Nicaragua, who seek to address humanitarian concerns and alleged violations of the Genocide Convention.
https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkiye-to-intervene-in-genocide-case-against-israel-193033
Poland: Warsaw Synagogue Attacked in Suspected Anti Semitic Incident
On 2 May 2024 in the early morning, Warsaw’s Nożyk Synagogue was attacked with three firebombs, also known as Molotov cocktails. A 16-year-old suspect was arrested in connection with the attack. The synagogue, which is the only one in Warsaw to have survived the Holocaust, sustained minimal damage and no injuries were reported. The incident has prompted condemnation from political leaders, including Polish President Andrzej Duda, and solidarity gestures from ambassadors of the U.S. and Israel, who visited the site with Jewish leaders and Polish officials. The attack is part of a trend of rising anti-Semitic incidents globally, particularly since the Israel-Hamas conflict in Gaza began in October, leading to increased hate crimes and discrimination against both Jewish and Muslim communities.
India: Several Refugees Deported Amidst Political Turmoil in Myanmar
On 3 May 2024, the state of Manipur in India deported 38 individuals back to Myanmar as part of efforts to address the influx of refugees fleeing political turmoil. This marks the completion of the first phase of repatriation, totaling 77 deportees since 8 March 2024. Manipur’s Chief Minister emphasised the impartiality of the process, highlighting the need to maintain border security and sovereignty. The deportations are a response to the crisis in Myanmar, where thousands have sought refuge in Manipur. While India is not a signatory to refugee conventions, some state governments provide aid to refugees. In neighbouring Mizoram, similar situations have occurred, with over 32,000 individuals seeking shelter. Despite challenges, Manipur remains committed to repatriating illegal immigrants, collaborating with Myanmar officials in the process.